India: Still no justice for Gujarat women and girls

Amnesty International
Nearly three years after violence erupted in the state of Gujarat in Western India those responsible continue to walk free.
The violence left over 2,000 people, mostly Muslims, dead. Several hundred girls and women were stripped naked, raped or gang-raped, had their wombs slashed and were thrown into fires, some while still alive.
A new report from Amnesty International "India: Justice, the victim - Gujarat state fails to protect women from violence" examines how officials of the state government, led by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), claimed that a fire on a train on 27 February 2002 was planned and caused by Muslims. It then took no steps to prevent or stop the widespread and systematic attacks by Hindu mobs on members of the Muslim minority which followed, and indeed many party and state officials were seen to participate. In many cases, these human rights abuses constitute crimes against humanity. The central government (until May 2004 also led by the BJP) failed to censure the government of Gujarat during and after the violence.

Now both governments must take effective steps to bring justice, truth and reparations to the victims. A litany of institutional failures added to the suffering of women like Bilqis Yakoob Rasool and prevented justice being done against their assailants. During the attacks, police stood by or even joined in the violence. When victims tried to file complaints, police often did not record them properly and failed to carry out investigations. Moreover, existing rape laws were too narrow to cover the wide range of abuses women suffered. Judges and prosecutors in many cases failed to protect witnesses from threats, sided with the accused and acquitted them.

"Little has been done to prevent such violence happening again," said Amnesty International. "The Gujarat state government must urgently make institutional changes, including gender-sensitisation training for police, judges, and prosecutors. Those who deliberately hampered the prosecution of offenders should be held to account. If the state takes no measures to remedy its failings, the victims will find it much more difficult to overcome their ordeal and regain a sense of safety." Indian human rights campaigners, national human rights organisations, national media and the Supreme Court have supported victims of violence and contributed to restoring hope at this late stage to some victims.

In August 2004, the Supreme Court ordered that over 2,000 complaints closed by police and some 200 cases which ended in acquittals of the accused be reviewed with a view to possible remedial action. For many victims, justice - if it comes at all - will come too late. "Many women were burned alive after they'd been raped, leaving no trace of the crimes against them," said Amnesty International. "Scores of other women never filed rape complaints - they were either prevented or were too afraid or ashamed to do so. These are the forgotten victims of the violence."

The report was shared with the governments of India and Gujarat prior to publication. Both governments provided detailed comments which are reflected in the report. For more information, visit: